marieToo
Posts: 3595
Joined: 5/21/2006 From: Jersey Status: offline
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: LadyEllen Hi Marie Thanks for explaining your position - you know, to some extent I agree with you, but I think its easier for those of us who have come through bad situations to forget how things were when we were in them. Hindsight is always more clear, I agree. But the way I see it is if I can use what Ive learned to help someone else, why not try? quote:
Yes, of course we are all responsible for our actions and their consequences - I can see this in my case now, but thats been a long road, on which hindsight has developed which allows me to see what actually happened rather than what I thought had happened. For those still in or just coming out of a bad situation, the view is not so clear, and what I feel they need at that stage is compassion and understanding, rather than the cold light of day. They will gain that objectivity for themselves, when they are ready, for themselves. I agree with that statement completely, I just happen to think that they may reach that point more quickely when friends try to focus them on solutions rather than on placing blame on themselves or others. quote:
Love and lust do blind us to what is actually in front of us in my experience, and can continue to blind us even when there is abuse. Its said that love is the triumph of optimism over reality (or something like that), and that I believe is all too often the case in abusive relationships. We hear from the battered wife that her husband is sorry and has promised he wont do it again, for the tenth time, and blinded by her love and optimism, she believes him and returns for more of the same. Love and optimism are I believe the original "flaws" in the one being abused, and whilst those outside the relationship implore her to leave, she will stay because she is blinded by them to the reality that the man she is with and his promises and love mean nothing. The abusee is guilty only of harbouring feelings which in other cases we would applaud. I wouldnt use the word 'guilty', Because I think thats a negative like blame and fault. But I hear what you're saying. It can and does happen. It happened to me in my own marriage ( I wasnt physically abused, but he was agrressive, scary, and threatening) He would always apologize and I would always forgive. And if someone had told me "Oh Marie, its ok, youre just guilty of loving him" I might have considered staying, because afterall, it only means that I love him, therefore its acceptable, because of that love, to live this way. I do understand compassion, and some "licking of the wounds" for a friend. But then I happen to think that helping them zero in on a solution would be more productive for them. I guess thats where Im coming from---a more of a solution-oriented attitude. Im sure kenin and others like himself will reach that point too. Its hard when you're going through it, but it does pass. quote:
I have an abusive relationship going on next door to me right now which demonstrates my points. My neighbour (Adrian) is an alcoholic - he may have stopped drinking for a week now, but however long that lasts he will always he an alcoholic. Last month he made "friends" with a bunch of heroin addicts in a pub here; two lads, two girls - because he fancied the girls. He invited them into his home, where they proceeded to "tidy" for him (he's typically untidy). When they left, he noticed that several of his possessions had gone missing, including an XBox. What was his reaction? The lads had stolen his stuff. The pretty girls could not possibly have done it. I told him over and over, to report it to the police and to never let them near the place again. What does he do? Invites the prettiest girl over again. More stuff missing. He refuses point blank to acknowledge it - blinded by lust, he now claims he loves her for goodness sake! Its not the first time he's had girls do stuff like this to him either - but whatever the circumstance he will go back for more, because she's a girl. None of the girls he has had in the last two years have loved him at all - every one of them has had issues which meant that their attraction to him was purely material or sexual. He will hear nothing of it though, even if he will finally acknowledge that the addict girl doesnt love him, because her only love is heroin - because he wants sex with her. He isnt stupid by any measure, but he is blind to her nature by his love and optimism. Hmmmmm.....this lad sounds like he may be blinded by his hardon. lmaoo. But dont tell him I said that. You make alot of good points, Ellen. Thanks for the civilized exchange of ideas. :)
_____________________________
marie. I give good agita.
|