RE: "Dropping off" an animal ... (Full Version)

All Forums >> [Casual Banter] >> Off the Grid



Message


kiyari -> RE: "Dropping off" an animal ... (2/21/2009 5:48:29 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: SomethingCatchy


quote:

ORIGINAL: TreasureKY

quote:

ORIGINAL: MissMorrigan

... why the OP when Firm knew of the kind of responses he was likely to receive. Emotional masochism.


Not hardly.  The reason Firm began this thread was because it was noted elsewhere that he and I always agree here on the forums.  While we do agree on most things, there are some areas where we don't... those areas just haven't made it onto the forums.

Well, now they have.  Voluntarily.  [;)]

Oh... and yes, Firm knew he'd catch hell for his position.  I said as much to him and expressed doubt that many people would take his side.  He made a good point in his response to me... they might not publicly admit it, but if so few people really felt the way he does, there'd be a lot less animal dumping going on.  Having lived 20 years in a rural setting, I do know that lots of dogs are dumped in the country.  I was fortunate in that the county I lived in at the time didn't charge to come pick up strays.






*shakes head* I can't believe I fell for the whole 'Lets start a controversial topic about animal abuse and shooting dogs in the head instead of putting them to sleep so that people can see that we don't always agree' game.


+1000%

kind of narcissistic, aint they?




TreasureKY -> RE: "Dropping off" an animal ... (2/21/2009 5:50:36 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: kiyari

+1000%

kind of narcissistic, aint they?


Only in a fun-loving, tongue-in-cheek way.  [;)]




Kalista07 -> RE: "Dropping off" an animal ... (2/21/2009 5:54:31 PM)

Firm
i will say 'publicly' that i'm not entirely convinced that You are doing it wrong. Animal control in the area i grew up in has always charged to drop off animals there. Last memory when i was little it was $50.00, however i can not be entirely convinced that You are wrong because every time my dad decided it was time to get rid of a pet (for various bullshit reasons) it was killed. The typically method was breaking its neck...................
i'll let Your imagination run from there.

By the way, the Tickey Kitty who resides with us was rescued when he was about 4 weeks old or so....i'm grateful we made it through those first two years of hell.

Kali




LaTigresse -> RE: "Dropping off" an animal ... (2/21/2009 6:02:32 PM)

In addition, regardless of why the thread was started.........

Almost all of my animals have been rescues. I do volunteer work with several shelters, working with agressive or "unadoptable" dogs. A greater percentile are rehabilitatible than most people think. The key is finding the proper home for each.

Another thing..........there are MANY no kill shelters all over this country. Most will take an animal,  no questions asked. Those I volunteer for do. They are also no kill. In addition, each animal adopted out must be spayed or neutered.

Unwanted, abused, mistreated animals are a touchy spot with me. Even both of my horses were purchased at auction, winning bid against kill buyers. Both are fantastic horses and perfectly healthy. There is a glut of animals in this country because people are irresponsible. I am not against euthanizing animals, I am very glad we can. I had to put one of my dogs down last week. It's terribly hard but it was a promise I made to myself years ago. I have the ability to give an animal a peaceful and non-suffering death. I will not keep an animal alive because I am too selfish to do the responsible thing.

I wish we could help our human terminally ill loved ones go as peacefully.




kiyari -> RE: "Dropping off" an animal ... (2/21/2009 6:04:34 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: LaTigresse

<snip>

I wish we could help our human terminally ill loved ones go as peacefully.


Now there is a serious issue.




TreasureKY -> RE: "Dropping off" an animal ... (2/21/2009 6:04:50 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: LaTigresse

I wish we could help our human terminally ill loved ones go as peacefully.


On that, I agree as well.




AScentofDarkness -> RE: "Dropping off" an animal ... (2/21/2009 6:05:18 PM)


I am not sure what prompted you (FirmhandKY) to post this....
Are you looking to be hated…
Are you feeling guilty…

I think dropping off an animal in the middle of nowhere IS giving it the death sentence, and you are the executioner. Shoot the animal, and know that it died quick, instead of being food for some other animal or starving, and dying a slow and painful death.
 




LaTigresse -> RE: "Dropping off" an animal ... (2/21/2009 6:11:41 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: Kalista07

quote:

ORIGINAL: kiyari

You are serious?

Drop an animal off and cross your fingers it will not meet some awful end?

You are condemning that animal to an odds-on  worse situation than merely putting it down.

Ah well, chalk another up for Firm, in the Firm and Treasure Freak Show Poll.


Apparently, You've never lived with the death of a pet at Your expense...

*edited to add* It continues to amaze and sadden me the number of people who have endless amounts of compassion, mercy, and sympathy for animals but could not must anywhere near those feelings for a woman, child, or another man.
Kali


I am not sure I understand this post. It reads to me, as though you would rather dump a sick pet than pay to have it euthanized. I would hope that is not the case.

I feel that if I cannot afford to pay for ALL of my pet's expenses..........I should not have the pet.




kiyari -> RE: "Dropping off" an animal ... (2/21/2009 6:12:44 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: AScentofDarkness


I am not sure what prompted you (FirmhandKY) to post this....
Are you looking to be hated…
Are you feeling guilty…

I think dropping off an animal in the middle of nowhere IS giving it the death sentence, and you are the executioner. Shoot the animal, and know that it died quick, instead of being food for some other animal or starving, and dying a slow and painful death.
 


Firm and Treasure are a pair.

They are playing the CC community with this pretend dissonance between them.

Showing us that they do not always agree on everything.

So we all can see... it is important, somehow, to them, that we all see this.

The topic is NOT the point, with this thread, for the OP and it's subbie.




LaTigresse -> RE: "Dropping off" an animal ... (2/21/2009 6:18:40 PM)

Who cares? It is still a valid subject, regardless of the intent of the OP. Why play into their game and turn it into a rediculous circus?




AScentofDarkness -> RE: "Dropping off" an animal ... (2/21/2009 6:18:44 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: kiyari

Firm and Treasure are a pair.

They are playing the CC community with this pretend dissonance between them.

Showing us that they do not always agree on everything.

So we all can see... it is important, somehow, to them, that we all see this.

The topic is NOT the point, with this thread, for the OP and it's subbie.


Well I will take your word for it.
I am new and usually just read the boards, but this upset me.




Kalista07 -> RE: "Dropping off" an animal ... (2/21/2009 6:20:15 PM)

LaT,
i apologize if i didn't communicate myself clearly. No, i don't agree with setting a sick animal loose rather than put it to sleep. But, my experience in this area is every time a pet angered my dad it was 'put to sleep' by him. The point i was trying to make was it's not a simple or easy decision to get rid of a pet...and when You don't have the money to put it asleep or drop it off at the pound....i don't know...i'm not sure what the best choice is.....

i will tell You though, that i love the Tickey Kitty that when things were worse for me financially, and i lived with a friend who had many other pets but didn't want tickey there i would cry to Him every night. In fact for a month tickey went to live somewhere else where he hated it and wouldn't come out to do anything. It seriously broke my heart. i would call Him everynight and cry about maybe i should just have tickey put to sleep because this all wasn't fair to the tickey kitty. i'm grateful to say that tickey LOVES living with Him and has been living here exactly one week more than i have... Truth be told i've told Him that my concern is that if a fire were to break out and He could only save one of use it would be tickey... :P
Kali




camille65 -> RE: "Dropping off" an animal ... (2/21/2009 6:22:44 PM)

Aside from my dislike of animal dumping what stood out to me was that you passed on a situation that you don't like instead of actually taking care of the situation.
Sure they aren't your responsibility but if you get bothered by pets being dumped on you, why do you turn around and dump them on someone else?

My last dog was a rescue dog, an amazingly sweet and loving Rhodesian Ridgeback mixed with hound. While I'm glad I wound up with her, it saddens me that someone had to scoop her out of a heavy traffic intersection in Detroit.

I could never purposely put an animal in the position.




FirmhandKY -> RE: "Dropping off" an animal ... (2/21/2009 6:23:02 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: Emperor1956

FR:  What do I think, Firmhand?   Well I am so glad you asked.

I think you are ignorant, selfish and ultimately in fact cruel to these dogs.  You are an animal abuser.   And your arrogance has you clothing it as something "humane".  

Let's parse this out.   You have read above the arguments (well made) of your ignorance in dumping the animal "in the wild".  You are simply pushing your problem on someone else.  I don't need to repeat those arguments.  However, you are also selfish,  in that you are choosing to salve your weak-minded conscience by claiming that you are being 'moral and respectful'.   In fact, you are shirking responsiblity and selecting out animals to suffer, with no regard for their future.  And you are cloaking your cowardice in your self-justification.  Why don't you simply sell the "excess animals" to a testing lab, or better yet, a dog fighting club?  Then you can be your badass macho self and make some money too!  The outcome for the animal -- likely misery -- is the same.

But worst of all, you are abusive.  No one else has focused on your oh-so-manly comment:  they were dangerous, or could not be trained to respect the physical integrity of the children, they were put down locally (usually with a 9 mm).  So, first, as one shooter to another, why a 9mm?  There is no reason to use a round that big, with that much muzzle velocity, to "put down" a dog and in fact it is very possible that the dog will not die a humane, painless death.  Bet you couldn't wait to kill something with your pistol.  But you had to make sure your admiring little chickadees who read your every word on CM knew you used a BIG MAN's gun, didn't you?

In fact, only a cruel person (or maybe a psychopath?) would shoot a dog to euthanize it.  Dogs survive head trauma amazingly well.  Can you swear that EVERY animal 'disposed of' this way died immediately?  I have worked in animal rescue for over 20 years and I have had "dead" dogs with head trauma wake up after being shot, clubbed or hit by a car.  They aren't at all healthy, but they aren't dead.  The only ethical and humane way to euthanize a dog is to use a drug cocktail administered intervenously, or to use a gas/decompression chamber.  But, hey, Firmhand, that would take all the fun out of it, wouldn't it?

Normally I ignore these posts.  But congratulations,  you have disgusted me into telling you exactly how I feel.  Now if you care to atone for your considerable wrongdoing, you'll make a sizeable donation to an AHSA-affiliated animal shelter in your area.  I'd say about $5000 would begin to erase the stain.  BEGIN to.  And THEN post the cancelled check, and maybe you could lecture us all on your morals?

E.

PS:  Kiyari, we do rescue here.  Current count is 3 dogs, 1 cat, 3 birds.   We do have one purebred, purchased cat (our last breeder-purchased animal before we decided that it was unnecessary to support animal breeding, although we both love purebreds).  Unfortunately there are now enough reckless "animal lovers" that even papered purebreds can be found in shelters and rescue societies. (and my profile is available on here...but oddly you need to type in 'Emperor'.  Dunno why, but CM never fixed it so I could have the same name in two places.)


You need to calm down.

I understand that it's an emotional issue, and I've had my share of troubled nights over the animals that ended up on my doorstep.

You are welcome to your opinion. If I still lived at the location I discussed, I guess the best thing for me to do is buy a small caliber gun, and the next time any dog that I didn't purchase or acquire showed up --- I should just walk out the door and start shooting.  Ought to be able to kill it after 4 or 5 shots.  If the 22's can get them in the heart.  Of course, I might just injury him, and he'd run away and die in agony.

Or just take a machete and run around the yard, swinging it, trying to hit on the neck enough to get them down where I can stomp their brains out.  Of course, having the rest of the pack chasing after us, baying and barking, getting in the way ... I might accidentally hit one of the animals I had taken responsibility for, ya know.  And the vision that my kids would see might contribute to a few nightmares, and visits to the local "head doc".

Of course, if the animal turned out to be one of my farmer neighbors, I'll likely get sued.

Call the Animal Control Office?  Well, when my county finally hired one ... no, wait, they had a volunteer who worked at it two days a week after the first 8 years I lived there .... but they finally did hire one guy full-time.... but he couldn't leave the shelter and make visits too ... so they started charging for visits so they could afford a second, part-time person, and so that the ACO could make visits occasionally.

After that, I started calling him, and one time, to get a couple of dogs, he came out on three separate occasions.  All the dogs ran away the first time, except for the house dogs.  I'm sorry he wasted a trip, but I didn't particular want him to give him my youngest son's favorite house dog ...

I still paid him his $20 for the visit.

The next time he came out to get the two dogs I specifically wanted gone, he had a problem with his noose.  And couldn't run fast enough to catch them anyway.  Finally he did catch one of them, but then the dog slipped out and he couldn't catch him again.

I paid him his trip fee again.

The third time, I had caught the dogs and penned them in, and put collars on them so that he could put a chain around their necks.  He got them that time.

I paid him his trip fee, and the fee for the two dogs.

'Course, all them thar "visit fees" meant I couldn't take the young'ens out to McDonald's that week ...

I'm sure glad that you guys up in Ill-e-noise have a different system.  Maybe us hicks down here in Kain-tuck-e should all move up there .... (you do have trailer parks, dontja?)

Of course, once these here pregnant bitches that got dropped on my doorstep ... I could've killed them pretty fast, if I had that "deadly cocktail" that you discussed.  Can I buy it at Wal Mart?  Or do I have to go to a "friendly" vet?

I'm real friendly with the vets around there.  Paid for one's first three kids' college education.  You'd be surprised how much it takes to buy pain medicine for a dog, especially after he's been hit by a car, and left in front of my house ... not to mention the times that someone else tried the "shoot em with the 22" and I had to get the bullets out, and provide a couple of days boarding at the vets ....

Back to those pregnant bitches that I "inherited" .... I was lucky that the Wal Mart was just a piece aways from the vet .... After I had all the puppies checked, dewormed, and given shots, my family and I could hang out around the store's entrance and beg people to take the cute lil fellars off our hands ... was pretty successful doing that (although kittens seem to go faster).

And, of course, Wal Mart let us do that, 'cause the local manager was use-ta me buying dog food in 50 pound bags ... use-ta come in two, three times a week.

Did I ever mention that I got kicked out of my garage when two bitches showed up, both preggers?

It was winter, and we had run out of human house, and dog house space ... and both were kinda skiddish to humans (can't understand why ... they had probably only gone a couple a weeks without a steady meal when we found them ...), so my ex bought a bunch of hay, and some boards, and some lamps for heat, and made me move all my stuff out ....

Twas eventually ok ... I got it back a couple of years later ... and I paid the hundreds ta get thar "feminine parts" ripped out ...

Of course, sometimes I had to make financial decisions about what I spent my money on .... shoes for my kids, or the vet bills, and dog food.

Sometimes thar jus' ain't no winning that battle.

But, of course, I'm a heartless, cruel, crowdly bastard who obviously should be arrested and sent to prison for life ... I once dropped a dog off!

Firm

I debated how to respond to you for a while.  I do understand it's an emotional issue for you, but I suggest that perhaps you are a might tooooo emotionally involved in the issue.

And, if you still feel like I oughter be tared and feathered, I'm saving two more words fer ya .... I'ls let ya guess what they are.




kiyari -> RE: "Dropping off" an animal ... (2/21/2009 6:24:05 PM)

tickey is truly loved, and no doubt gives it back tenfold




kittinSol -> RE: "Dropping off" an animal ... (2/21/2009 6:28:44 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: camille65

Aside from my dislike of animal dumping what stood out to me was that you passed on a situation that you don't like instead of actually taking care of the situation.
Sure they aren't your responsibility but if you get bothered by pets being dumped on you, why do you turn around and dump them on someone else?


Not to mention the fact that, aside from the moral cowardice of abandoning animals, when left to themselves dogs sometimes revert to the wild animal within them and form packs. This is potentially dangerous to human beings.




FirmhandKY -> RE: "Dropping off" an animal ... (2/21/2009 6:30:31 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: Kalista07

Firm
i will say 'publicly' that i'm not entirely convinced that You are doing it wrong.


You are a brave women.

I, on the other hand, am obviously a coward. [:D]

Firm




TreasureKY -> RE: "Dropping off" an animal ... (2/21/2009 6:31:32 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: kiyari

Firm and Treasure are a pair.

They are playing the CC community with this pretend dissonance between them.

Showing us that they do not always agree on everything.

So we all can see... it is important, somehow, to them, that we all see this.

The topic is NOT the point, with this thread, for the OP and it's subbie.


To be honest, I'm not sure why it really matters to you whether or not Firm and I agree.  I made my position clear at the beginning of the thread and left it at that.  There's been no playing of anyone, our discordant opinions have not been showcased, and my disagreement is genuine.

The point of the thread remains regardless.  Is it really your job to invalidate the emotions and opinions of everyone who have posted here?




littlewonder -> RE: "Dropping off" an animal ... (2/21/2009 6:36:54 PM)

So after reading all of this....

First..so you can't bring yourself to get all of these dogs that suddenly show up on your doorstep, neutered/spayed and then you just drop them off in the wood somewhere...couple months later you get pregnant bitches showing up suddenly on your doorstep that you now have to take care of and probably eventually dump in the wood again...

Ya know if you would have gotten them neutered/spayed in the first place maybe you wouldn't have so many showing up on your doorstep?

Just a thought




kiyari -> RE: "Dropping off" an animal ... (2/21/2009 6:38:38 PM)

I am guessing it's all more or less theoretical, here.

Arbitrary topic, pretend stances.




Page: <<   < prev  2 3 [4] 5 6   next >   >>

Valid CSS!




Collarchat.com © 2025
Terms of Service Privacy Policy Spam Policy
0.046875