BamaD -> RE: England will fight to the last American. (2/20/2013 12:23:28 AM)
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: TAFKAA quote:
ORIGINAL: BamaD The French didn't show in force until Yorktown, the last battle of the war, claiming they won the American revolution is exactly like claiming that it was the Americans won WW I and II for you. No, it was the Battle of the Chesapeake which made all the difference, preventing - as it did - the reinforcement of Yorktown by the British fleet. Given that the fledgling colonies had NO ships of the line, it would have been impossible for the American revolutionaries to have contested Chesapeake bay without the help of France. The French threw a couple of dozen into the fray, forcing Yorktown to survive unaided against the combined forces of the French and American armies. The significance of the materiel which the French sold to the Americans should not be underestimated. Without a manufacturing base for weapons and ammunition, you have to get your guns and ammo from somewhere. It should also be pointed out that Washington was definitely no military genius and lost battles many times. As with most history, an accurate assessment is difficult but I think it's fair to say that without French involvement, the United State as we know it today would not exist. Yes I am aware of all that I view the battle of Chesapeake bay to be part of the Battle of Yorktown. You will never catch me claiming Washington was a great or even a particularly good general his best military quality was his ability to keep the army fighting. Arnold (before West Point) Morgan, Greene and several others on or side were better at fighting battles. And their supply help was invaluable. However this was in response to the assertion that the French won the war.
|
|
|
|