Phydeaux
Posts: 4828
Joined: 1/4/2004 Status: offline
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: Hillwilliam quote:
ORIGINAL: Hillwilliam quote:
ORIGINAL: Phydeaux Uh, no. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Northwest_Passage A few in 2012. Perhaps a dozen in 2009, with two cruise ships A cruise ship in 2007 A couple in 2003 one in 2001 The MS explorer (cruise ship) in 1984 Coast guard ship in 1957 (not an icebreaker) A variety of steel hulled, and ice tolerant ships have made it in other years. Point is, its not the first time the waters were navigable. I think the scarcity of points speaks more to a lack of desire and lack of attention previously than any real AGW trend. That's right. According to YOUR source, it has been traversed in 2009, 2010, 2011 and 2012. That's every recent summer. I said dozens of SAILORS, not ships. Please learn the difference. Here's the point. Explorers started looking for the NWP in 1497 They were blocked by ICE Finally, one of the greatest polar explorers of all time made it in THREE YEARS because of, you guessed it, ice. 1n 69, a specially reinforced tanker made it thru with the help of FOUR icebreakers. Now, recreational sailors make the trip for fun because there's less.....wait for it.....ice The stuff that blocked human efforts and trade for over 5 centuries is now gone for a significant time every year. I never said this is the first time the waters were navigable, that was technically the 03-06 trip I said this is the first time that it is routinely navigable as seen by recreational sailors making the trip. Your words were "Now, it's done every summer by dozens of amateurs in pleasure boats." Please have some intellectual honesty. That simply isn't true. Specially built and /or inflatable boats that can go over ice don't count. They are, for the most part, neither amateurs nor pleasure boats. The dates that were sailed are the dates indicated. A few (3?) in 2012, and perhaps a dozen in 2009. Since it was 9 boats, you provide no backup to say it was dozens of sailors either. It could be as few as.. 9. None in 2010, 2011, 2013. So, it isn't every summer, it isn't dozens, it isn't routine, it isn't amateurs, and it isn't pleasure boats. Other than that your statement is perfectly accurate. But, more to the point, you pointed to it as breathless evidence of AGW, ignoring the fact that a cruise ship did it in 1986. If you refer back to my graph of temperature distributions over the last hundreds of thousands of years, you can see that temperatures seem to vary on a cycle. You have no evidence to suggest that the temperature variation that we are seeing now is anything other than the natural variation that has occurred.
|