freedomdwarf1
Posts: 6845
Joined: 10/23/2012 Status: offline
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: quizzicalkitten Whats silly is you brits quote that because you have these great gun laws your country is so safe, now you have people using knives, so you are asking your people to turn in your knives. Its not about dying its about the fact that you ban guns because they kill people and lead to crime..... and its made your country no more safer to violent crime and problems.... whats after knives no glass because someone can break it and use it to fight with.... Your *cough* Great *cough* country has 64 million people roughly the US has 316 million people almost 5 times the amount of people your country has... and yet we only have 16% more violent crime then your country.... and in total crime you have 3 times the amount as the us... and you have two times more the amount of rape cases then the us. So yeah us gun toting americans have it all wrong... I mean wanting to hold on to ways to defend ourselves.... is just silly, I mean... its not like knife crime will increase with the banning of guns. I mean the UK is SO peaceful, what with more rape then america victims then us... more overall crime.... We totally have it wrong seriously how the fuck do you have more rape when we have 5 times the amount of people then you... HOW do you FAIL that greatly... http://www.nationmaster.com/country-info/compare/United-Kingdom/United-States/Crime And here is someone who has actually done the maths to draw a proper comparison rather than quoting the media myths: http://dispellingthemythukvsusguns.wordpress.com/ Just some highlights from the text - .....Therefore, it becomes practically impossible to draw any objective comparison between the two, unless one trawls through the various definitions of crimes that can be said to be the same in definition and execution in the UK and the US. I’ve actually done this, and by going through the PRC and FBI – CUS it is possible, I believe, to find a number of crimes which I think are fairly indicative of the prevalence of “violence” in either country. To this end, I have isolated robbery, burglary, homicide / murder, knife crime, fatal shootings, rape of a female, grievous bodily harm / aggravated assault and theft of a vehicle in order to give us a fair idea of which country is more “violent.” Interestingly, this suggests that the actual violent crime rate for the US is 4.81x higher than reported (NCVS 5.800.000 / 1,203,564 FBI – CUS = 4.81) and 2.6x higher than reported than in the UK. (CBS 2,203,000 / 821,957 THOSB – CEW = 2.6) Unfortunately, as I’ve said, it is impossible to use these figures against one another. However, it is indicative of a few things. Firstly, that crime has a higher rate of being reported in the UK than in the US, as the UK’s survey rate is more closely matched by police reported crime. Secondly, it illustrates by how much crime appears to be under-recorded in the US, by an order of 4.81 exactly. You are thus 1.1x (135.7 / 113.7) more likely to suffer robbery in the UK than in the US. You are thus 1.52x (702.1 / 460.1) more likely to suffer burglary in the US than in the UK. You are thus 4.03x (4.6 / 1.14) more likely to be murdered in the US than in the UK. You are thus 1.27x (58.3 / 45.8) more likely to be knifed in the UK than in the US. You are thus 35.2x (3.17 / 0.09) more likely to be shot dead in the US than in the UK. You are thus 1.02x (26.7 / 26) more likely to be raped as a female in the US than in the UK. You are thus 6.9x (241.05 / 34.7) more likely to suffer aggravated assault in the US than in the UK. You are thus 1.29x (229.5 / 176.9) more likely to suffer theft of a vehicle in the US than in the UK. Conclusion: In sum, it becomes clear that an objective comparison between any two countries types of offenses is a difficult and time consuming endeavour. In order for it to be done properly, matching definitions need to be found, and umbrella terms that group large numbers of what one country may class as offenses and the other not, must be avoided. Statistics must be broken down to their bare bones and compared accurately and objectively if any meaningful parallels are to be found. I hope that above, I have shown not only the truth, but also nothing may ever be taken at face value. I would welcome any others who decided to base their comments and views on similar grounds, rather than the vitriolic and groundless drivel I will no doubt be expecting. I don’t even expect more than a fraction of you will have read this far. And if you have, it is clear WHY the United States IS more violent than the UK. This guy's report doesn't just take the media figure verbatim. He breaks the crime reports into their constituent parts and makes a proper per capita comparison between the USA and the UK. Of all the crap you can dredge up for crime stats, this seems to be the most comprehensive and properly adjusted set of numbers to make a decent comparison. In other words, some that has done their homework and the maths and come up with something sensible.
_____________________________
“If liberty means anything at all, it means the right to tell people what they do not want to hear.” George Orwell, 1903-1950
|